6 Best Long-Term Care Insurance Companies Experts Rate Highly

Planning for a future where you remain in your home requires more than just physical modifications; it demands a solid financial strategy. Long-term care insurance is a critical component of that strategy, providing the resources to fund the support you may need to live independently. Choosing the right carrier is a decision that can secure your ability to age on your own terms for decades to come.

Friendly Disclaimer : This content is for educational & general research purposes only. Please consult healthcare providers or other qualified professionals for personalized medical, caregiving, or health-related advice.

Friendly Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you for your support!

Why Long-Term Care Insurance Is Key for Aging in Place

Imagine wanting to stay in your home but needing help with daily tasks like meal preparation or medication management. Without a plan, the cost of a home health aide can quickly deplete savings, forcing a move you never wanted. This is where long-term care (LTC) insurance becomes the financial bedrock of aging in place. It’s not just about covering a nursing home; it’s about funding the services that make independence at home possible.

A well-structured policy provides a dedicated stream of income to pay for skilled or non-skilled care in your own residence. This could mean hiring a professional caregiver, an occupational therapist to adapt your home, or even adult day care for social engagement. It transforms the question from "Can I afford to stay home?" to "What support do I need to thrive at home?"

By planning for these potential costs, you protect your retirement assets from being liquidated for care expenses. This preserves your financial legacy and, more importantly, gives you control over your environment. The right LTC policy ensures that a health event doesn’t automatically mean a change of address, empowering you to make choices based on preference, not financial necessity.

Mutual of Omaha: Top-Rated Financial Stability

When you buy a long-term care policy, you’re making a pact with a company that may not need to pay out for 20 or 30 years. That’s why an insurer’s financial strength is paramount. Mutual of Omaha consistently earns high marks from rating agencies like A.M. Best, providing confidence that the company will be there to honor its commitments when you need it.

Their traditional LTC policies are known for being comprehensive and straightforward. You can typically customize key features like the daily benefit amount, the benefit period (how long the policy pays out), and the elimination period (the initial waiting period before benefits begin). This allows you to build a plan that directly reflects your anticipated home care needs and budget.

Mutual of Omaha often includes valuable built-in benefits, such as care coordination services. A professional care manager can help you and your family navigate the system, find qualified local caregivers, and develop a plan of care. This expert guidance is an invaluable resource for making the transition to receiving care at home a smooth and organized process.

New York Life: A Legacy of Policyholder Trust

As a mutual company, New York Life is owned by its policyholders, not stockholders. This structure aligns the company’s interests with yours, as profits are often returned to policyholders in the form of dividends. For over 175 years, this model has built a reputation for stability and a policyholder-first approach, which is exactly what you want in a long-term partner.

New York Life offers asset-based or "hybrid" long-term care solutions. These policies combine life insurance with an LTC benefit rider. This design solves a common concern with traditional LTC: what happens if you never need care? With a hybrid plan, if you don’t use the LTC benefits, your heirs receive a tax-free death benefit.

This "return of premium" feature provides peace of mind that your investment isn’t lost. It creates a defined outcome for the funds, whether they are used for your care at home or passed on to your family. For those who want to ensure their premium dollars serve a purpose regardless of future health, this structure is a powerful and efficient planning tool.

Northwestern Mutual for Potential Dividends

Northwestern Mutual is another highly-rated mutual company that stands out for its potential to pay annual dividends. While not guaranteed, the company has a long and consistent history of paying them. For LTC policyholders, these dividends can be a significant financial advantage over the life of the policy.

You can typically use these dividends in several strategic ways. Many choose to apply them to reduce future premiums, making the policy more affordable over time. Others might use them to purchase "paid-up additions," which effectively increases the policy’s benefit pool without additional medical underwriting. This acts as a powerful, built-in inflation hedge.

This dividend feature makes a Northwestern Mutual policy a dynamic financial instrument rather than a static expense. It allows your policy to potentially grow and adapt alongside your needs. For disciplined planners who appreciate efficiency, the ability to have their policy’s performance help fund itself is a compelling reason to consider this carrier.

Lincoln MoneyGuard for Hybrid Life/LTC Plans

Many people hesitate to buy traditional LTC insurance because they worry about paying premiums for a benefit they might never use. Lincoln Financial Group’s MoneyGuard solution was designed to directly address this "use it or lose it" dilemma. It’s a hybrid universal life insurance policy with long-term care riders, ensuring your premium dollars have a guaranteed purpose.

Here’s how it works: you pay a premium, which establishes a pool of money for long-term care. If you need care at home, you can draw from this pool tax-free. If you pass away without needing significant care, your beneficiaries receive a life insurance death benefit. If you simply change your mind down the road, many policies offer a return-of-premium feature.

This structure provides a clear, triple-A benefit: Assistance if you need care, Asset for your heirs if you don’t, and Access to your money if your plans change. For those seeking certainty and a defined outcome for their investment, the MoneyGuard model offers an elegant and popular solution.

Brighthouse SmartCare for Simplified Hybrid Plans

While hybrid plans are appealing, some can feel complex. Brighthouse Financial, a spin-off from MetLife, designed its SmartCare policy with an emphasis on simplicity and clarity. It offers an indexed benefit structure, meaning your LTC benefits and death benefit grow at a guaranteed compounding rate, making it easy to project future values.

The underwriting process for SmartCare is often more streamlined than for some traditional policies, which can be an advantage for applicants. The plan is designed to provide a guaranteed outcome: your benefits will grow by a set percentage each year, taking the guesswork out of inflation protection. This predictability is a major plus for long-range financial planning.

Brighthouse SmartCare is a strong choice for individuals who value straightforward mechanics and guarantees. It provides the core benefits of a hybrid plan—coverage for care, a death benefit for heirs—in a package that is easy to understand and manage. It’s an excellent fit for the planner who wants to set it, forget it, and know exactly what they have.

NGL EssentialLTC for Customizable Coverage

For the planner who wants granular control over their policy, National Guardian Life (NGL) offers one of the most customizable traditional LTC plans on the market. Their EssentialLTC product allows you to fine-tune nearly every aspect of your coverage, ensuring it aligns perfectly with your specific vision for aging in place.

This flexibility is especially valuable for integrating with state Long-Term Care Partnership Programs. These programs allow you to protect your assets from Medicaid spend-down requirements, and NGL’s policies are designed to meet the specific criteria. You can also select from a wide range of benefit periods, inflation protection options, and elimination periods.

NGL also offers unique riders, such as a joint policy option with a shared benefit pool for couples and a survivorship benefit that waives premiums for a surviving spouse. This level of customization allows you to build a policy that isn’t just a safety net, but a precision tool designed to fund your exact home care plan without paying for features you don’t need.

Choosing the Right LTC Policy for Your Home Care

Selecting the right company is only half the battle; structuring the policy correctly is what truly empowers you to age in place. The goal is to match the policy’s features with the practical realities of receiving care at home. A financial advisor specializing in LTC is invaluable here, but you should go into that conversation with a clear understanding of your goals.

Start by considering the "benefit trigger." This is what qualifies you for benefits, typically the inability to perform two of six Activities of Daily Living (ADLs) or a cognitive impairment. Ensure the policy has a clear and fair definition. Next, look at the "elimination period," which is like a deductible measured in time. A 90-day period is common, but you need to be prepared to self-fund care for those first three months.

Finally, and most critically for a long-term plan, is inflation protection. The cost of a home health aide will be significantly higher in 20 years. A 3% or 5% compound inflation rider is essential to ensure your daily benefit amount keeps pace with the actual cost of care. Without it, a policy that seems adequate today could fall short when you need it most, undermining your goal of remaining comfortably and safely at home.

Ultimately, long-term care insurance is a declaration of independence. By researching these top-rated carriers and carefully structuring a policy, you are not planning for decline; you are investing in your continued autonomy. This proactive step ensures you have the resources to call the shots, adapt your home, and live a full life in the place you love.